Abstract
Abstract This chapter considers the right to marry, expressed in human rights law, alongside recent calls for the state’s relationship with marriage to be minimized through disestablishment. The chapter makes two main claims. First, if calls for disestablishment are motivated by a desire to better protect and secure the right to marry for all citizens, establishment fares equally well on that front. The marriages offered by civil society alone will not be sufficient to protect that right. Second, if there is no right to marry, this does not mean that marriage is devoid of normative value. Although justice may need to focus on the broader category of intimate, caring relationships, instead of the narrow category of marriage, securing justice for all such relationships does not preclude the establishment of marriage. The chapter argues that it is permissible to accept and retain the cultural value of marriage, in cases where justice is not violated or compromised.