arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Social Sciences · Political Science and International Relations

How social security in Britain compares to other countries

Paul Spicker

· Policy Press eBooks

See on the map

Abstract

Social security systems have been compared in three main ways: models of idealised welfare regimes, reviewing the rules and structures of benefits and looking at the combined effect of benefits on final income. It is difficult to generalise, because what is true for one part of a system is not necessarily true of others, but the relative performance of the UK tends to be mixed, and some way from the model of the ‘welfare state’. Policy cannot be easily transferred from other countries, but comparisons can at least draw attention to a broader range of methods and mechanisms. Much of the literature in social policy is interested in how policies in one country compare with others. The idea of the ‘Welfare State’ tends to give the impression that social security in Britain can be understood in systematic terms, as a coherent whole. Part of the problem with that assumption is that there are too many principles, policies and approaches being applied for it to be possible to sum up the system in a neat formula. Equally, there are many ways of doing things, and many of the countries we might reasonably think of as ‘welfare states’ – countries like Sweden, France or Germany – approach the problems differently. Comparative social policy has tended to focus on the operation of welfare states as a whole. Social scientists who want to be able to generalise about policy can do it most effectively by looking at patterns across a range of different national experiences. The distinction between residual and institutional welfare has been the starting point for a wide range of classifications and typologies of welfare states.

More like this