arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Social Sciences · Education

A Contrast of Novice and Expert Competence in Maths Lessons

Gaea Leinhardt

See on the map

Abstract

An approach to the study of teaching is to consider it as one of the more interesting and complex cognitive processes in which human beings engage, and to analyse the tasks, resources and constraints in which teachers are enmeshed. With this perspective, one stands figuratively behind the shoulder of the teacher and watches as the teacher juggles the multiple goals of script completion (Putnam, 1985), tactical information processing, decision making, problem-solving and planning (Leinhardt and Greeno, 1986). In studying this cognitive skill, we attempt to identify the elements of expertise that are involved. One method for doing this is to contrast experts’ performance with that of novices. Although there are limits to the expert–novice research paradigm, such contrasts provide a useful beginning in the quest for information about the nature of expertise (Voss et al., 1986). Novice–expert contrasts have proved fruitful in the study of complex cognitive tasks such as playing chess (Chase and Simon, 1973), solving physics problems (Champagne, Gunston and Klopfer, 1983; Chi, Feltovich and Glaser, 1981) and note taking (Hidi and Klaiman, 1983). To highlight the dimensions of competence in elementary mathematics teachers, we have contrasted the performance of experienced and highly competent or expert teachers with that of new or novice teachers. In so doing, we hope to characterise the dimensions of competence in terms of not only what experts do well, but also what function each competency serves. The ultimate goal is to understand expertise well enough to develop instruction for novice teachers which will make their early performance more expert-like, and, eventually, to move the performance of all teachers into the expert range.

More like this