arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Social Sciences · Political Science and International Relations

“Silent but Powerful Preachers”: Southern Religious Pamphlet Literature during the Civil War

Josh Waddell

· Civil War history

See on the map

Abstract

“Silent but Powerful Preachers”Southern Religious Pamphlet Literature during the Civil War Josh Waddell (bio) During the height of the Civil War, as battles between Union and Confederate armies raged on, Baptist preacher Basil Manly Jr. proclaimed, “There is another war, however, in which we are engaged with a deadlier foe than the Yankees.” This battle, the South Carolinian maintained, was fought not on the front with guns but in the hearts and minds of Southern troops. Indeed, Manly, along with the vast majority of Southern ministers, thought the Civil War constituted “spiritual warfare.” In their view, God controlled events on the battlefield, and He would ultimately choose the most just and righteous side. The Lord, however, had not predetermined the victor; both combatants had the opportunity to gain God’s favor or squander His blessing. How then could the South gain God’s approval?1 For many religious ministers, the answer lay in the conversion and righteous behavior of the soldiers. Joseph C. Stiles, a Presbyterian minister, implored the servicemen to “put away all your profanities, all your dishonesties, all your intemperance, all your Sabbath breaking, all your straggling, [and] all your desertion” for these actions were “working mightily to strengthen Federal arms, to achieve Federal victories, and to crush the liberties of the people.”2 [End Page 268] The ministers did not, however, deliver these messages in sermons to the elites of Southern society but in pamphlets sent to soldiers by religious publishing societies. Throughout the war, these organizations produced and delivered hundreds of tracts to the servicemen concerning the status of their souls and the sacredness of their cause. The importance of the production of these writings becomes apparent when, as Drew Gilpin Faust notes in The Creation of Confederate Nationalism, “the South had only one typefoundry, no facilities for printing maps, insufficient numbers of paper mills, and an entire inability to make wood-pulp paper.” Even with the scarcity of printing supplies, the South produced millions of pages of religious literature and Bibles.3 The Confederacy also displayed a commitment to the spiritual well-being of its soldiers by providing salaries for army chaplains. Partially due to Faust’s contribution, religion has continued to play a growing role in how scholars have understood the War’s significance, especially to those who fought it.4 Though many scholars have furthered our understanding of religion’s role in the War, some paths remain underexplored. When assessing the religiosity [End Page 269] of the South and Civil War soldiers, for instance, many researchers focus on chaplains as opposed to the various forms of print material sent to soldiers. Despite the attention paid to them by posterity, these regimental ministers had varying levels of effectiveness on the troops, especially for the many soldiers who had no chaplains.5 The study of religious print compliments previous research by allowing for a more expansive view of nineteenth-century religious thought and the spiritual lives of Civil War soldiers. The most notable study of religious print during the War comes from Kurt O. Berends’s essay in Religion and the American Civil War, in which he discusses the Confederate religious military press (RMP). In these newspapers, clergymen, as writers and editors, reported current events with Confederate sympathy, often adding religious analysis. Berends argues that the RMP “created and explained a framework of beliefs—a worldview—that sustained an unvanquished optimism for southern independence.” These periodicals shared many themes with religious pamphlets (one of the articles printed in the RMP became an independent tract), but the newspapers remained grounded in the reality of current events, no matter how much the authors skewed them in Confederate favor. Berends’s analysis followed his sources, thereby putting less emphasis on theology and the impac

More like this