arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Social Sciences · Sociology and Political Science

Review of “The Invention of the “Underclass”: A Study in the Politics of Knowledge”

Nicolas Duvoux

· Social Forces

See on the map

Abstract

In his last book, Wacquant used the 1977–1997s debates on the “underclass” as a tool to study a wide array of interconnected actors and distinct meanings on the one hand and to deconstruct and then reconstruct a sound social science of advanced marginality and beyond on the other hand. Loïc J.D. Wacquant is a French-born sociologist who has been a key contributor to the renewal of the study of (the crumbling of) the (black) ghetto since the 1960s by merging this (too) dynamic field of research with aspects of a mostly European long-term and reflexive epistemology. Two decades earlier, he provoked controversy by severely criticizing three of those he considered the best urban poverty ethnographers of the 1990s (Anderson, Newman, and Duneier), highlighting their collaboration with a neoliberal view of the poor. In The Invention of the Underclass, he develops his critique of their “moral empiricism” in one of the “normalized empiricism” of some of the most influential urban poverty researchers (including William Julius Wilson, one of his academic mentors, to whom the book is dedicated). This particular style of sociology is applied to a wide array of disseminated producers of “knowledge” involved in the making and unmaking of the “underclass” at the crossroads of academia, policy-philanthropy, and journalism.

More like this