Abstract
Reviewed by: Thucydides John Marincola Jeffrey S. Rusten (ed.). Thucydides. Oxford Readings in Classical Studies. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2009. Pp. x, 519. $65.00 (pb.). ISBN 978-0-19-920619. Thirty years ago Nicole Loraux, in a watershed article entitled, "Thucydide n'est pas un collègue," warned that we cannot evaluate the great fifth-century historian using our own modern categories while simultaneously ignoring generic conventions and/or minimizing the contemporary context of the history itself and its author. Although it would be over-simplification to suggest that Thucydidean scholarship of the past generation has mainly tried to work through the consequences of her observations, it is nevertheless true that the contextualizing and defamiliarizing of Thucydides have been leading aspects of recent work on the historian. Jeffrey Rusten does not include Loraux's article in his splendid collection for the Oxford Readings series, but its spirit permeates many of the studies here. Rusten acknowledges that no collection of sixteen articles can aspire to the status of a canon, yet within the limits of this series he has produced an excellent and representative selection of important work done on Thucydides over the last thirty years. It is a particular pleasure to see here a number of articles not previously available in English: Hermann Strasburger's groundbreaking study of Athenian self-representation in Thucydides, Nicole Loraux's brilliant analysis of the stasis in Corcyra episode of Book 3, Joseph Vogt's perceptive study of Thucydides' portrait of Pericles, Bernd Manuwald on Diodotus' manipulative rhetoric in his debate with Cleon, Jacqueline de Romilly on the narrative strategies in play in Thucydides' account of the battles at Syracuse, and Roberto Nicolai's stimulating discussion of Thucydides' reception in antiquity. Anglo-American scholarship is well represented also. W. R. Connor's seminal study, "A Post-Modernist Thucydides?" opens the collection, and is [End Page 368] followed by Kenneth Dover's "Thucydides 'as History' and 'as Literature'" (arguing that separating these two aspects of the historian leads to distortion) and Simon Hornblower in typically learned fashion on Thucydides' contemporary intellectual affinities (a chapter from his 1987 Thucydides). It is a pleasure to see here Lowell Edmunds' "Thucydides in the Act of Writing" and Carolyn Dewald's "The Figured Stage: Focalizing the Initial Narratives of Herodotus and Thucydides," both important contributions previously available only in difficult-to-acquire Festschriften. Christopher Pelling's chapter (from his Literary Texts and the Greek Historian) on the speeches is a brief but extremely thought-provoking piece, one that well considers Thucydides as both history and literature. Tim Rood's "Thucydides' Persian Wars" is a model of how to do intelligent and imaginative intertextual studies when working with historiographical texts. Brian Bosworth's contrarian "The Humanitarian Aspect of the Melian Dialogue" is a refreshing reexamination of a text too often read with deep-seated preconceptions, while H. D. Westlake's "Thucydides and the Uneasy Peace: A Study in Political Incompetence" shows the high level of narrative complexity in book 5, a book usually seen as unpolished. Hans-Peter Stahl's "Speeches and the Course of Events in Books Six and Seven of Thucydides" convincingly argues the necessity of reading logoi and erga together as mutually illuminating. The volume ends with a section on reception, featuring Nicolai's article (mentioned above), Jonathan Scott on Thucydides and the English Civil War, and Josiah Ober on the dangers of assimilating Thucydides too closely to modern "Realist" theories of international relations. One notes the absence of Colin Macleod and Adam Parry, two scholars whose influence has been profound, certainly in English-language scholarship; but presumably their inclusion was less urgent since each scholar's collected pa