Abstract
Afterword Rodrigo Lazo Some years ago, before starting graduate school, I travelled to the Galápagos Islands. As someone originally from Ecuador, I was aware that the islands are a province of the "República del Ecuador" but also very far from the coastal and Andean regions that are the economic and political strongholds in my country of birth. Anyone who has managed to reach that archipelago knows that to experience the natural variety of the group it is necessary to navigate from one enchanting island to another. Galápagos tourism has always relied on local small boats and yachts taking tourists to the different islands, and it was aboard the appropriately named Albatross that I stumbled on a collection in the ship's tiny library containing "The Encantadas; or, Enchanted Isles." The sketches offered Galápagos lore shared by guides as part of the visit—stories of buccaneers and castaways. It also became quickly apparent that the sketches did not seem to be about the islands before me. As I stared at the volcanic formations and contemplated the friendly animal-life, the Galápagos looked nothing like "five-and-twenty heaps of cinders dumped here and there in an outside city lot" (Piazza Tales 179). Nor were they as elusive as Salvator R. Tarnmoor's delusional account conveys. While I do not regularly look for veracity in fiction—and Melville's invocation of sites and references in South America are not always invested in accuracy—the difference between what I apprehended in the Galápagos and the sketches prompted questions that continue to hang like an albatross around my neck: Why was a writer associated with US literary nationalism engaging with locations that were distant to his New England home and also distant from the part of Ecuador where I had been born? And what kind of referential weight did these sketches carry for Melville's work and, more generally, the way people in the United States view Latin America? With those questions foremost, I note that three of the five pieces in this special issue on Melville and the region we are calling "Spanish America" place "The Encantadas" at the center of their arguments and take a variety of approaches: philosophy and epistemology, questions of allegory, and a US-centric historicism. Those very different critical directions appear to pull away [End Page 103] from Spanish America and remind us of the complicated relationship of "The Encantadas" to the geographic destination that inspires its organization. Anna Brickhouse, for example, argues that the sketches dwell in "a space of philosophical rupture, a vantage point for meditation on the West: its enduring problem of evil, its invention of the human, and its perpetual creation of theodicies that justify the world's racial and geographical apportionment of suffering" (37–8). In connecting her interpretation to Western thought more generally, Brickhouse offers a more ample terrain than the very geographic location that draws the sketches. Taking a different approach, Yoshiaki Furui reads "The Encantadas" in relation to the temporality of the discourse of Manifest Destiny and the teleology of Euro-American modernity. These types of shifts should be no surprise given that, as I have noted, the Galápagos themselves are geographically and culturally distant from the mainland. Long uninhabited by humans, the islands are "Spanish" only in the poetry of colonial assumption. Both historically and in Melville's sketches, the Galápagos are distant geographically from the area we associate with Spanish America. As such, "The Encantadas" offers a series of literary and cultural dislocations and critical navigations that send readers in a variety of directions. The contributors to this special issue follow that spirit and see "Spanish America" as an opportunity for departure as much as a necessary critical stopping point when reading Melville. The special issue makes a convincing case for the importance of "Spanish markers" as a set of refere