Abstract
Control Orders, brought in under the UK 2005 Prevention of Terrorism Act, may be seen as little less than a form of house arrest without due process of trial, and, as such, do not benefit from the safeguards of the usual court process, however, the UK Government believe that the measures are proportionate and necessary in order to safeguard the UK population at large against a perceived threat from Terrorism. The Courts have given various rulings in the cases, considering Article 5 of the European Convention on Human Rights, and lately, the Law Lords have been extremely critical of the system, ordering the government to reconsider control orders imposed on eight terrorism suspects, since in six cases, the control orders included an 18-hour curfew, whilst in another two cases the proceedings had breached a right to a fair hearing. The recent (2009) judgements concerning the use of closed material and the response of the Secretary of State to those judgements seem to show an increasing trend towards the Judiciary in the UK advocating a more transparent approach. Clearly, the needs of the legislature and the checks and balances supplied by the judicial system are in conflict, and, with consideration of the Articles of the European Convention of Human Rights, together with UK case law, this paper will seek to examine both the background to the basis on which this conflict may be resolved.