arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Social Sciences · Education

Editorial

Anila Asghar, Aziz Choudry, Teresa Strong‐Wilson

· McGill Journal of Education / Revue des sciences de l éducation de McGill

See on the map

Abstract

EditOriALWe would like to open this issue, which marks nearly the end of the second year of our tenure as MJE co-editors, and of the second complete MJE volume that we've shepherded through the publication process, by thanking our reviewers.Over the journal's almost fifty years, our reviewers have come to number almost two thousand (as we learned through a recent count).It is not the faceless two thousand that we wish to acknowledge here, but the individuals behind that daunting number: the ones who, over the course of the last two years, we, as 'green' editors, have relied upon to give of their time in providing appraisals of pieces in various states of being ready (or not yet) for publication.These individuals are academics (established and emerging) who work or conduct research at various universities, English and French, across North America and around the world.As newcomers to journal editing, we hadn't given a great deal of thought to reviewing; it was something that we understood was important to do as academics but that we very much took for granted.In two years, we have learned a great deal from our reviewers, lessons that have no doubt informed our own practices as reviewers for other journals, including "being good" by respecting deadlines: a small but crucial part of the review / publication process.As Anthony Paré, previous editor of the MJE, has remarked (45, 1), the amount of time most reviewers give to thoughtful and often long and detailed reviews is chastening, especially when we consider that reviewers perform this service for a given piece not once but frequently twice, and when we also consider that the value ascribed to academic reviewing (a cornerstone of the publication process, on which we all rely) is rapidly being eroded in favour of other so-called priorities; where even reviewing has become the focus of "cherry-picking:" of being implicitly or explicitly encouraged to undertake only those guaranteed to stand out on a CV or for the purposes of securing merit.And yet we would not be able to exist as a peer-reviewed, open access journal-a common space for scholarly dialogue and exchange on issues important to education locally, nationally and internationally-without that "essential service."All the more reason to take the time to heartfully say: thank you, reviewers!We at the MJE appreciate the work that you have done for all of us, and hope to be able to call on you again in the future.All the best for the new year!

More like this