Social Sciences · Sociology and Political Science
Participation and Power: Civic Discourse in Environmental Policy Decisions
See on the mapAbstract
Participation and Power: Civic Discourse in Environmental Policy Decisions. By W. Michele Simmons. New York: SUNY Press, 2007; pp. ix + 204. $60.00 cloth; $21.95 paper. When Congress created legislation requiring public participation in environmental policy decisions, the need for communication citizens about risk and its assessment arose. Though it has been over forty years since Congress first passed such legislation, current often limit public participation a cursory role. One of the goals of Simmons's research in risk communication is improve the democratic participation process required by law and policy. Her work not only contributes theories of risk communication, but also examines problems in the public sphere, highlighting practical implications for both pedagogy and community participation in environmental issues at the local and national levels. As the cases Simmons examines reveal, there are many levels on which institutions and publics intersect and conflict in the policymaking process. Risk communication offers several models for explaining risk citizens. However, as the author points out, these models are often arhetorical-typically decontextualizing risks, failing consider the knowledge local citizens can contribute, and striving influence/educate citizens in order bring their perceptions into conformity with scientific rationale (1). To ensure more ethical and just risk communication practices, Simmons proposes ways address and mediate that conflict. To do this, she examines risk communication in selected historical and contemporary environmental policy decisions. She is concerned with discovering what inhibits and what encourages significant public participation in order develop a new rhetorical model of risk communication based on participatory design. In Chapter One, Simmons explains that risk communication and its associated models developed in response conflicts between experts' assessment of risk and the public's perception of it. These models were intended facilitate public participation; in reality, they tend be problematic, often hindering or even preventing true public involvement in policy decisions. The author argues that current practice, based on traditional risk communication models, fails allow for true participation by citizens and is therefore both unethical and unjust. Reviewing studies by other risk researchers, Simmons highlights the insights and limitations of these studies, which, according the author, have failed to examine the institutional conditions that promote or prevent citizen participation in the decision-making process of environmental policy as a way develop a more just approach risk communication practices (3). After reviewing the literature, briefly examining key institutions involved in these decisions, and introducing her major case--the Newport Chemical Depot--the author lists the questions the book addresses and explains her methods for data collection and analysis. Based on her study of historical and firsthand institutional cases, Simmons develops both a theory of public involvement that is just and ethical and a risk communication model that invites more genuine public participation and control in the decision-making process. Simmons's theoretical frame is influenced by Habermas's theory of communicative action, Foucault's theory of power structures, and Iris Marion Young's ideas on democratic participation. Ultimately, she suggests a rhetorical model of risk communication--a heuristic that can be applied not only public participation in policy decisions about environmental concerns, but also any policymaking situations in which there are multiple stakeholders. Reviewing problems in past cases is important developing this new model. In Chapter Two, Simmons explores citizen involvement in environmental policy across a spectrum of historical cases. …