arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Social Sciences · Education

Teacher Quality: Issues and Research

Cay Evans, Pamela M. Stewart, Martha C. Mangin, Candi Bagley

See on the map

Abstract

Teacher Quality: Issues and Research Teacher quality is at the top of the education policy agenda. From private foundations such as the Thomas B. Fordham Foundation to the U.S. Department of Education and further, reaching to the 2000 Presidential campaign, the debate about quality rages. There are hundreds of governmental and private groups studying quality and making recommendations for improving quality. So many different reports, edits and standards, in fact, that it is can be quite confusing to teachers themselves and to higher education institutions whose role it is to train the nation's teachers, as well as the lay person, parent, who is concerned about his/her child's education. This current attention to quality stems from a number of factors. In 1996, the National Commission on Teaching and America's Future published a report making the case that well-qualified teachers make a big difference in children's learning. At the same time, Recruiting New Teachers, a nonprofit organization, began warning of a large number of impending retirements which would result in shortages of qualified teachers. As the movement grew, local school systems began toward higher academic standards and accountability systems which led to the same conclusion ... teacher quality would ultimately determine the success of such efforts (Sack, 2000, p. 25). Proponents of quality have known this for some time but described the lack of qualified teachers as an unspoken problem. However, the above factors that intertwined over a series of years to create the education reform movement have brought an acute awareness to the problem. The status of the education reform movement can be summed up by John F. Jennings, the Director of the Center on Education Policy, We have exhausted ourselves talking about standards and accountability and choice. Now, we've come to realize a lot depends on who's standing at the front of the classroom (Sack, 2000, p. 29). With that realization, then, comes the question, what impacts the quality of the standing in front of the classroom? The purpose of this paper is to present an overview of some of the issues surrounding the debate over quality including pay and incentives, school staffing, and preparation. The issue of pay and incentives usually focuses on three alternative methods to a uniform salary schedule: (1) pay-for-performance, (2) differential pay and (3) financial incentives. Pay-for-performance, commonly known as merit pay, ties teachers' salaries to student achievement. Many states and organizations are currently supporting the concept of pay-for-performance for teachers. Two organizations that have come out in favor of this approach are The Business Roundtable (BRT) and the National Alliance of Business (NAB). In 2000, they published an issue brief, Pay-For-Performance in Education: An Issue Brief for Business Leaders in which they described how pay-for-performance salary structures could reward teachers for improving student achievement. Also, districts across the country are making in this direction. For example, in Colorado, Douglas County has negotiated a new contract which ties pay raises to student performance, and the California Board of Education, in July, 2000, approved a plan that will give teachers and schools cash bonuses for improving student achievement on standardized tests (Pay-For-Performance, 2000). Not all are in favor of such plans. The National Education Association (NEA) Representative Assembly voted in July, 2000, to adopt a resolution opposing performance-based pay (National Education, 2000). Differential pay refers to paying teachers more if there is a shortage allowing districts to respond to market conditions and pay teachers differently. One group that strongly supports differential pay is the Education Trust group. …

More like this