arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Social Sciences · Sociology and Political Science

Hume. Two Volumes

Stephen R. Grimm

· ˜The œreview of metaphysics

See on the map

Abstract

DUNN, John and HARRIS, Ian, eds. Hume. Two volumes. Great Political Thinkers, vol. 10. Cheltenham, United Kingdom: Edward Elgar Publishing, 1997. 1,137 pp. Cloth, $380.00--This two-volume reference work attempts to bring together all of the notable essays on Hume's political thought during this century, a whopping 59 pieces ranging in time from 1906 to 1995. The essays have not been reformatted but are rather facsimiles of the original versions, virtually all of which are gathered from journals. The overall shape of the volumes thus resembles something a graduate research assistant might produce, if in addition to a xerox machine he also had access to a good binder. The collection is intended, however, not merely for scholars without the benefit of assistants, but more importantly for those whose libraries do not subscribe to all the journals from which these articles are culled. This is an admirable goal; however the considerable price tag places a significant onus on the volumes to prove their worthiness. Although there is certainly excess fat which could be trimmed from these two weighty volumes, the editors should be commended, among others things, for including a handful of articles which challenge one of the unspoken, yet widely obeyed dicta regarding Hume's political thought: that Hume's extensive historical writings, especially his six-volume History of England, really had little impact on his theory of government, property, social utility, and so forth. One could, indeed, read many treatments of Hume's political philosophy without finding even a mention of his historical work, as if the two were easily divided and compartmentalized. More recently, however, scholars such as Donald Livingston have brought attention to the essentially historical nature of Hume's of man, and the editors have acknowledged this important development in some of their selections (see, for example, articles by A. J. Beitzinger, James Moore, Victor Wexler). The argument for the importance of the historical dimension of Hume's political philosophy is uncomplicated, but because it is still not popularly accepted it bears repeating. As the article by Beitzinger (vol. 1, pp. 183-200) demonstrates, the argument has three main steps: (1) If politics is to be reduced to a science (as Hume's famous essay by that title indicates), then it must exhibit some regularity. Specifically, we must be able to find social motives and inclinations which are common to all people. (2) As an extension of his empiricism, Hume holds that we can only understand the nature of human beings by observing how they function; an observer newly arrived from Mars, according to Hume, would see no inherent connection between a given situation and a person's response to it. A priori claims about the essence of man are not possible. (3) The perhaps unexpected conclusion of these two straightforward premises, however, is that if human beings are to be the objects of our observation, then this observation must take place on a suitably large scale and in a suitably large laboratory. …

More like this