Social Sciences · Political Science and International Relations
Rethinking the International Criminal Court as the court of its state parties
See on the mapAbstract
The International Criminal Court has tended to be imagined as a necessarily universal jurisdiction in the sense that it should aspire to have universal membership and is justifiable by appeal to universal principles. I contend instead that much can be gained by seeing the Court as not only de facto but in a normatively defensible way, the Court of its states parties. I therefore imagine a future for the ICC that is much like its present of representing a sizeable but limited portion of the international community. Rather than justifying the Court’s existence in top-down fashion based on the significance of the crimes it represses or the values it embodies, the chapter takes seriously the strictly horizontal and cooperative elements that go into its making. In order to do so, it first grounds the creation of the Court in the sort of strategies deployed individually by states that join it and through which they seek to protect themselves from the harm associated with international crimes. It then argues that this unit-level analysis focused on the national interest must be complemented by a more systemic attention to the fundamentally collective nature of the international criminal justice endeavor. The Court can then be understood as a regional alliance that imposes a certain protective discipline but also expresses a form of solidarity between like-minded states. The chapter concludes with reflections on the significance of the downgrading of grandiose but hypothetical justifications of the Court. The consequent provincialising of the ICC as the court of a particular community of states leads to a paradoxical but ultimately promising best-case scenario.