Abstract This chapter provides a new reading of Locke's Letter concerning Toleration in light of the preceding chapter's study of his earlier opposition to toleration. Though he initially believed toleration was a threat to peace, he came to believe that toleration could in fact secure peace but only if most believers could first be convinced on theological grounds that supporting a policy of governmental neutrality did not itself violate loyalty to God or neighbor. Having offered a new account of Christian political theology to harmonize loyalty to God and toleration in this way, Locke was then, but only then, to advocate a policy of abstract respect.