arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Social Sciences · Political Science and International Relations

The Rationality of Toleration Revisited or, Why Locke Thinks We Should Suffer Disagreement and Tolerate Division

Douglas John Casson

· Perspectives on Political Science

See on the map

Abstract

Much of the confusion and debate surrounding the rational basis for Locke’s notion of toleration rests on the assumption that Locke seeks to convince a single, sovereign authority to tolerate dissenters. Yet this is not Locke’s goal. In the Two Treatises of Government, he describes a polity with multiple claimants to supreme authority under changing conditions. He proposes a state without sovereignty. The cohesion of this state stems not from the organizing power of a centralized authority, but from the multiple and contested judgments concerning the justifiable use of power. Locke’s arguments in his Letters Concerning Toleration can best be understood as part of this sweeping challenge to sovereignty. He shifts the focus of the debate from the rationality of the ruler to the rationality of the ruled. Instead of appealing to the “sovereign remedy” to cure the ills of religious and political division, Locke turns to the informal power of shared norms. He believes that the social mechanisms of praise and blame (rather than the machinery of criminal punishment) will more effectively nurture tolerant dispositions and just communities. Yet Locke ultimately justifies toleration and the norms that sustain it because he believes them to be in accordance with reason or natural law.

More like this