Social Sciences · Law
The Meaning of the Presumption of Innocence for pre-trial detention. An empirical approach
See on the mapAbstract
What is the presumption of innocence (PoI)? In a nutshell, Anthony Duff’s thought provoking argument purports that there is not one but many (interconnected) PoI. One of those is an important principle for restricting pre-trial detention. Duff’s account of the meaning of the PoI is intellectually challenging and a pleasure to read. Duff takes a normative point of view – how should the PoI regulate pre-trial detention. He is not primarily concerned with how the PoI actually regulates pre-trial detention and how it is practiced. My contribution will particularly focus on the latter perspective. Accordingly, section 3 describes the results of my empirical research into the argumentation of Dutch judges (for what reasons do they order pre-trial detention?) and also outlines several other national practices. Hence, I will confront Duff’s normative PoI based pre-trial detention theory with pre-trial detention practice. But first, in section 2, in order to better understand Duff’s position, I will discuss the relation between the PoI and pre-trial detention as seen by Duff, other scholars, and the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR). The central question to this contribution thus is: what can be seen of (Duff’s or other) PoI in pre-trial detention practice?