Social Sciences · Demography
Social Security, Teacher Pensions, and the "Qualified" Retirement Plan Test.
See on the mapAbstract
About 5 million state and local government workers, including 1.2 million public school teachers concentrated in 15 states, are not enrolled in Social Security. In order to ensure that those workers receive adequate benefits, Congress requires state and local government employers to offer qualified retirement plans, or they must automatically enroll their workers in Social Security. To define a “qualified retirement plan,” the IRS uses a “safe harbor” provision that sets minimum thresholds for defined contribution and defined benefit retirement plans. Prior work has demonstrated that the safe harbor provision applied to defined benefit plans is focused on the benefits workers may receive at the end of their career, which does not account for how individual workers may accrue retirement assets throughout their working careers. In this paper, we extend the existing literature to look at different types of workers who enter and exit the teaching profession at various ages. After defining those sample profiles, we calculate how their retirement benefits would accrue in either Social Security or state-run retirement plans. We replicate this analysis for each of the 15 states that do not enroll public school teachers in Social Security. We find that, depending on the state, when teachers enter and exit teaching can have significant effects on their benefit levels. For some groups of teachers, they must serve for many years before qualifying for retirement benefits that are at least as generous as Social Security.