Social Sciences · Sociology and Political Science
Before the Flood
Geoffrey S. Baird, Trevor Bedford, Michael Boeckh, Chloe Bryson‐Cahn, Helen Y. Chu, Seth A. Cohen, Nancy E. Davidson, Peggy Douglas, Timothy H. Dellit, Janet A. Englund, Laura Evans, Jeff O Gates
See on the mapAbstract
A ripple led to a wave, and the wave led to a tsunami that ultimately landed, somewhat quietly, on the shores of Washington State. Our healthcare teams didn’t know then that cases introduced from outside the United States would lead to silent transmission and spread of severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) into our communities—out of sight and out of our control. We should have been mobilizing as a nation but were lulled by quarantines and travel restrictions, as policy makers called the virus a hoax, and to articles falsely claiming that the virus was an escaped bioterrorism agent. Americans were more worried about politics than about biology. Like any virus, SARS-CoV-2 is engineered by nature, not in a laboratory, to spread easily and undetected—a particle so small and yet able to bring a nation to its knees. Colleagues in Seattle at the University of Washington, University of Washington Medicine, Fred Hutchinson Cancer Research Center (Fred Hutch), Seattle Cancer Care Alliance, Seattle Children’s, and the Brotman-Baty Institute were not unprepared. Based on results from a large community surveillance study (the Seattle Flu Study) previously organized to track influenza and other respiratory viruses, SARS-CoV-2 testing was rapidly implemented to detect early cases: this ultimately identified genetic evidence of community transmission in Washington State. Statisticians and modelers had warned of worldwide spread and voiced ominous predictions. In preparation, our virology laboratory had been working diligently since January to develop an assay to detect the virus. We considered the effect of the global situation on our healthcare systems, we prepared for catastrophe, and administrators heeded our warnings. Despite all we knew and prepared for, unforeseen weaknesses in our nation’s preparedness hamstrung our responsiveness. Regulatory frameworks delayed community access to testing. Weak links in the supply chain limited our ability to procure additional sanitation supplies and personal protective equipment (PPE). Global supplies were sapped by early outbreaks and disruption of production outside the United States. Most importantly, restrictive testing criteria and limited capacity crippled our ability to detect and follow local cases and epidemiologic patterns. These challenges gave the virus a chance to establish a beachhead. In fact, when astute clinicians [1] and our surveillance systems detected the first community-acquired cases, genomic analysis and predictions from Fred Hutch scientists told us we were already behind the epidemic curve. SARS-CoV-2 began spreading during respiratory virus season, when mild cases were not recognized. Many with the illness likely worked in our communities because working when sick is tacitly expected in our culture. It is unclear how much asymptomatic shedding played a role in spread, but without awareness of local transmission, we couldn’t encourage important steps such as staying home when sick, telework, and social distancing. Furthermore, many employees lack paid sick leave or work multiple jobs. From custodians to baristas, many couldn’t work from their couches and still get paid [2]. This says nothing of those needing child or elder care for their families. Still, our science experts and savvy community providers gave us a chance. We learned from our colleagues in China, Iran, Italy, South Korea, and elsewhere that older adults and those with chronic illnesses are most vulnerable. Among these groups, many who get infected will become ill, and many will die. We also learned about the inherent limitations of any healthcare system—even sophisticated, well-resourced ones—to manage an influx of acutely ill patients. Our systems are not equipped to withstand a flood. Nonetheless, our hospital staffs learned much in the early days of the COVID-19 pandemic. We worked through challenges in screening, triage, and PPE availability. We moved quickly from airborne precautio