Social Sciences · Political Science and International Relations
The Epistemology of Democracy
See on the mapAbstract
The relationship between democracy and epistemology is tense. In theory, democracy embraces commendable epistemic ideals that in practice it seems doomed to violate. Despite its laudable epistemic ideals, real democracy is at best an epistemically mixed bag. Largely reacting to Walter Lippmann, John Dewey introduced two reorientations that have since become central to theorizing the epistemic dimensions of democracy. First, Dewey contends that democracy is not primarily a form of government, but a type of society, a “way of life”. Second, Dewey promotes an epistemology that takes inquiry as the primary epistemological activity. Inquiry, Dewey holds, is fundamentally the social process of experimentally addressing emergent problems. The deliberativist framework opens several distinctive avenues of research concerning the epistemology of democracy. The chapter discusses three major and interlocking trends: the epistemic capabilities of groups; vulnerabilities to group-epistemic pathologies; the epistemic character of public discourse.