arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Social Sciences · Political Science and International Relations

The review of "Philosophical Foundations of Human Rights"

Jelena Belić

· PhilPapers (PhilPapers Foundation)

See on the map

Abstract

Moral and legal rights have been a subject of an intensive philosophical investigation, but until recently, human rights were left aside.Yet, once philosophers turned their attention to human rights, it appeared that the concept raises numerous controversial questions, starting from the most basic one: what are human rights?Philosophical Foundations of Human Rights is the first edited collection of essays featuring contributions by well-known philosophical and legal scholars that aims to address these questions in an all-encompassing manner.The book is organised into four parts that contain 38 chapters in total covering a broad range of issues.Part 1 deals with the moral grounds of human rights, such as dignity, agency, interests and needs.Part 2 discusses some of the political and legal dimensions of human rights regime.Part 3 focuses on specific human rights, some of which are canonical, such as freedom of speech or of religion, while others are more contested, such as a right to democracy or to subsistence.Finally, Part 4 goes back to more philosophical dilemmas by considering human rights from a set of critical perspectives, including relativism, feminism and Kantian views.Each part takes a dialogic form by containing several pairs of chapters each of which includes a defence of a specific position as well as a critical response to it.Such a dialogic structure gives a balanced approach to controversial issues, illustrating how challenging it is to sustain any particular position concerning any dimension of human rights.Since the topics covered are so numerous and diverse, it is impossible to address all of them within this review.For this reason, I will limit the review to what I take to be the most novel contributions of each part.Part 1 is concerned with the foundations of human rights-are human rights grounded in fundamental moral ideas or we should search for its foundations somewhere else?It offers a new take on often discussed grounds of human rights, including dignity and a good life.It starts with John Tasioulas's pluralist interest-based account (Ch.1) that grounds human rights in a plurality of values that includes both a moral value, which is dignity, and prudential elements, which are human interests.Therefore, human rights are grounded in the universal interests of all human beings, each of which possesses an equal moral status arising from their humanity.For Tasioulas, such pluralist grounding has a two-fold advantage over alternative accounts of human rights.First, it can explain in what sense human rights are resistant to trade-offs.Since it is equal dignity that explains why interests generate human rights, it also ensures that rights of each individual matter equally.Secondly, by combining dignity with interests, it can offer a more determinate content of human rights, which pure, status-based accounts cannot.Importantly, rights have to be "compossible" in a sense that fulfilment of rights of everyone has to be jointly feasible (e.g.there can be a right to an adequate standard of living, but not a right to a luxurious life).In response, Onora O'Neill (Ch.2) adds that besides compossibility of rights, duties entailed by these rights have to be

More like this