arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Social Sciences · Political Science and International Relations

A Union Indivisible: Secession and the Politics of Slavery in the Border South by Michael D. Robinson

Keith S. Hébert

· The Journal of Southern History

See on the map

Abstract

Reviewed by: A Union Indivisible: Secession and the Politics of Slavery in the Border South by Michael D. Robinson Keith S. Hébert A Union Indivisible: Secession and the Politics of Slavery in the Border South. By Michael D. Robinson. Civil War America. (Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 2017. Pp. xvi, 294. $34.95, ISBN 978-1-4696-3378-7.) Many histories of the secession crisis overlook border South states. Michael D. Robinson's A Union Indivisible: Secession and the Politics of Slavery in the [End Page 1000] Border South addresses those past omissions and presents a compelling argument that border South states chose to remain in the Union because it offered the best chance of protecting slavery. Robinson's well-researched regional history provides fresh insights into how slavery divided a region that, as did many Americans, "occupied a political middle ground" between radical elements in the North and the South and conservatives across the nation dedicated to preserving the Union (p. 10). A Union Indivisible thus sheds much light on broader questions concerning American politics and regionalism in the late antebellum period. Robinson seeks to understand how most white men in the border South chose to remain loyal to the Union. The author treats the border South as a "corporate entity" (p. 11). The region's politics fell within a large gray area that existed between two polarizing radical political movements: abolition and secession. On the eve of the secession crisis, the border South was far from a Unionist bastion. Fire-eaters and proslavery defenders had successfully infiltrated the region and reinforced the narrative that residents of the border South had more in common with their lower South brethren than with their northern counterparts. Although the border South differed from the lower South in many ways, the two regions shared a mutual concern for the future preservation of slavery. Slavery's declining role in the regional economy failed to shift the area toward antislavery politicians, who often found their voices muted by pro-slavery defenders. The aftermath of John Brown's raid at Harpers Ferry challenged the border South's conservative middle ground. The threat of violent abolitionism and its influence on radical political movements provided ample ammunition for proslavery zealots who sought to erase that middle ground. In Brown's wake, a new political party emerged, the Constitutional Union Party, that attempted to forge an alliance among moderates who sought refuge from the escalating partisan politics that had swept through both the Democratic and the Republican Parties. While moderation failed to win over many voters outside the border South, the new party successfully managed to stave off secessionists who attempted to use Brown's raid as kindling to ignite the region's proslavery passions. The 1860 presidential election revealed the limited influence that moderate politics held over the nation. Many border South voters threw their support behind Constitutional Union Party candidates in the hopes of preserving both the Union and slavery. When the Constitutional Union Party failed to draw a majority of American voters to their platform, the border South's chosen middle ground ironically contributed to both the Union's dissolution and slavery's eventual abolishment. As states began to secede, the border South clung to its tentative middle ground by embracing conditional Unionism—an effort by moderate factions to maintain neutrality in the growing sectional conflict in the hopes of protecting the region's interests. Robinson is at his best when providing an insightful examination of the politics of conditional Unionism. During the war, border South Unionists gained the upper hand as President Abraham Lincoln steadfastly refused to allow the region to secede and dispatched to the area large numbers of Federal soldiers, who tempered secessionist leaders. Unionists successfully convinced a majority i

More like this