arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Social Sciences · Political Science and International Relations

Redefining Science: Scientists, the National Security State, and Nuclear Weapons in Cold War America

Sarah Bridger

· Journal of American History

See on the map

Abstract

In this clear and accessible book, Paul Rubinson poses a stark question: Given so many American scientists' deep commitment to arms control, why were they so unsuccessful at influencing nuclear policy? He argues that Cold War anticommunism—epitomized by the revocation of Robert J. Oppenheimer's security clearance in 1954, which he sees as a crucial turning point—“redefined” science and its relation to government. In his rendering, arms control scientists quickly internalized the lesson to make only calm, technical arguments upholding the premise of nuclear deterrence. Those who chose, instead, to offer deep moral critiques faced marginalization from government and from fellow scientists. Dividing scientists' nuclear arguments into moral and technical categories, Rubinson attempts to trace how this redefinition affected crucial debates over a nuclear test ban, arms control and disarmament, nuclear winter, and the Strategic Defense Initiative. This shift, Rubinson argues, impeded scientists' ability to deescalate the arms race. Rubinson's most significant contribution is his assessment of scientists' argumentation. His chapter on nuclear winter documents thoroughly both the technical skepticism and political disapproval that Carl Sagan faced in the 1980s. Public debates were rarely the full story, however. Discussing the test ban campaign, Rubinson contrasts Linus Pauling's powerful moral crusade against radioactive fallout with the “technical advice” of government scientists, whose failure “to develop arguments effective enough to challenge the advocates of nuclear weapons” resulted in only a partial ban (p. 115). Despite Pauling's broader goals, the moral condemnation of fallout effectively prioritized ending atmospheric, not necessarily underground, testing. White House records show that behind the scenes, science advisers' technical and political arguments successfully persuaded President John F. Kennedy to keep an underground ban on the negotiating table. The limited scope of the 1963 test ban thus had more to do with Soviet posturing than the rhetoric of scientists. Unfortunately, Rubinson has neither consulted these kinds of internal documents nor has he fully parsed the policy implications of the rhetoric he cites.

More like this