Social Sciences · Sociology and Political Science
We can work it out? Examining Barriers to the Disruption of Polluting Practices in US Communities
Horacio Enrique Rousseau, Pascual Berrone
See on the mapAbstract
Drawing on the institutional work literature and community studies, we examine the barriers that undermine the ability of local environmental organizations to disrupt highly polluting practices. Using a comprehensive longitudinal dataset of 300 communities in the United States, we find that a stronger presence of environmental nonprofits significantly reduces community contamination. However, elite prevalence, visible enforcement actions, and community financialization, all negatively moderate this effect, therefore supporting the notion that certain community factors can hinder the institutional work of environmentalists. We also find conservative political ideology increases the tolerance for polluting practices, but it does not directly undermine the effect of environmental nonprofits. Finally, and contrary to our expectations, we find that community heterogeneity - racial and national origin diversity -enhanced the ability of nonprofits to challenge polluting practices. This result indicates that community diversity can indeed be a source of opportunity for organizations engaged in efforts to deinstitutionalize hazardous practices. Our findings therefore allow us to understand the conditions under which the efforts of organizations working for the disruption of undesired institutional arrangements are more likely to be effective. Our study also offers practical insights for policy makers and leaders in community-oriented nonprofit organizations.