Social Sciences · Urban Studies
‘A NIMBY Charter’ or ‘The Cornerstone of Good Planning’?: Views on Community Engagement from the Coalface of the Planning Profession
See on the mapAbstract
Planners are key players in the delivery of the Government’s ‘Sustainable Communities’ agenda, as recognized by the Egan Review (2004). A key part of this agenda is community engagement which, although a feature of British planning ever since the Skeffington Report of 1969, now forms a cornerstone of ongoing planning reforms across Britain. Academic discussion about such participatory planning has tended to focus on theoretical discussions or detailed local case studies. Whilst such studies are useful, they fail to provide a synoptic overview of the now considerable experience in Britain with participatory planning or to consider the key role of the planning professionals in carrying it out. This paper draws on my ongoing research examining how planners as a professional group are responding to these ongoing planning reforms to analyse how they think about community engagement processes. Empirical data from a recent extensive UK-wide survey and in-depth interviews help illustrate planners’ heterogeneous perceptions and experiences of participation, revealing support in principle for community engagement but difficulties and negative attitudes towards participation in practice. I conclude by linking these reactions to ideas of professional expertise and public service ideals of a serving the interests of a ‘silent majority’.