Social Sciences · Political Science and International Relations
How Complete an Overthrow: Religious Conversion and National Character in Some Nineteenth Century Novels of Ancient Britain
See on the mapAbstract
In 1863 Charles Kingsley wrote, Truth, its own sake, never been a virtue with Roman clergy. Father Newman informs us that it need not, on whole ought not to be.1 John Henry Newman, famously, responded with Apobgia pm vita sua in which, after majestic narrative of process leading to his conversion, he turned to particulars of Kingsley's accusation.There are a number of issues at stake in this exchange. immediate question was whether Newman's word could be trusted. Newman asserted, vigorously, that it could. scorn detest lying, he insisted, and quibbling, double-tongued practice, slyness, cunning, smoothness, cant, pretence, quite as much as any Protestants hate them.2Behind this issue lies another one: question of whether one can owe allegiance to Church of Rome, still possess character loyalties proper to a subject of crown. kind of national anxieties about loyalty that go back to reformation, are embodied, instance, in story of Guy Fawkes, received fresh energy in nineteenth century from Newman's secession wave of conversions that followed it, still more in aftermath of Papal Aggression of 1850 in which Vatican re-established Catholic hierarchy in England. In 1851 prime minister wrote to bishop of Durham that the liberty of Protestantism has been enjoyed in England too long to allow of any successful attempt to impose a foreign yoke upon minds consciences.3 Kingsley's distrust of Newman's character was part of this broader concern about a fundamental incompatibility between Englishness Catholicism.Newman also directly addressed this broader issue. His dedication to Church of Rome, he insisted, was unqualified: since his conversion he had no anxiety of heart whatever . . never have one doubt.4 To be Catholic, however, was not to trade in some essential Englishness an essential foreignness: his word his character were still entirely those of an Englishman. Much as I admire high points of Italian character, he wrote, like rule of conduct better.5 Moreover, he insisted that this combination of dogged allegiance both to Church of Rome, to character of England was characteristic not just of him but of Catholics at large: he wrote that on his conversion he was particularly struck by English out-spoken manner of priests, among whomthere was nothing of that smoothness, or mannerism, which is commonly imputed to them, they were more natural unaffected than many an Anglican clergyman. many years, which have passed since, have only confirmed my first impression. I have ever found it in priests of this Diocese; did I wish to point out a straightforward Englishman, I should instance Bishop, has, to great benefit, so many years presided over it.6Englishness, he insisted in face of popular suspicion hostility, was perfectly compatible with Catholicism.Beneath both of these questions lies a third, broader one, concerning relationship between religious allegiance national character: a question which was further entangled with pervasive Victorian concern with origins. century's great narrative historians were deeply interested in implications of history origins self-understanding of contemporary Englishmen were ardent in their insistence that Englishness was synonymous with Anglo-Saxonness. John Richard Green wrote that for fatherland of race we must look far away from England itself.7 William Stubbs asked who were forefathers, whence did they come, what did they bring with them? answered that the are not aboriginal.8 Edward Augustus Freeman repeatedly describes Angles Saxons as our own forefathers,9 applauded savagery with which heathen invaders slaughtered native inhabitants, because it secured purity of Anglo-Saxon racial cultural heritage: The were thus able to grow up as a nation in England, their laws, manners language grew up with them were not copied from those of other nations. …