Abstract
In spite of so much activity in both penal practice and penal discourse, criminal justice continues to be a disaster. It is a disaster in its own, lately clarified terms: it does not reserve prison for serious offenders, since prisons continue to be full of minor property offenders; it does not apportion punishments fairly, since the rich continue to get fines, suspended sentences or administrative processing, whilst the poor, the mentally disordered, blacks and migrants get penalising processes and prison; it does not protect the public, since crime rates continue to soar; it does not legitimate the system, since prisoners have become more prone to riot and the public has become more prone to criticise the police, the courts, the correctional services and the politicians. By any broader utilitarian or sociological standards — lessening the oppressiveness of the state, increasing citizens' dominion over their own lives, promoting social cohesion and harmony; in other words, contributing to social justice — criminal justice is not only ineffective but also pernicious. On all counts, therefore, criminal justice stands in urgent need of reform. This chapter will put forward some ideas for reform that disenchantment with the outcome of revamping of penal codes has made newly acceptable, or brought to the verge of acceptability. These are ideas generated from within the system itself by sympathetic critics or by commentators who, whilst not exactly sympathetic to current practice, at least accept that the penality characteristic of late capitalism is susceptible to reform, rather than needing total abolition. This, then, is the penal agenda of the reductionists, the realists and the moral pragmatists.