Social Sciences · Communication
The Function and Importance of the Television Police Show in Shaping Public Understanding
See on the mapAbstract
In this book, I have endeavoured to produce an account of the process of storytelling during the 26-year history of the television police drama The Bill and on nine other police dramas, eight British and one French — Between the Lines, The Cops, The Vice, The Ghost Squad, Scott & Bailey, Broadchurch, True Crimes, Suspects and Spiral. Previous commentators (Clarke 1986;Reiner 1994;Rafter 2006;McLaughlin 2007) have suggested that changes in the storytelling process in television drama are, in part, due to shifts in public attitude, changes in the political climate and changes in the genre. I suggest that in the case of these dramas, a complex and interlocking set of factors, including commercial imperatives, working processes, the fluctuating economic climate of the television industry and the constraints of the format, also played a part in determining representation of the police, policing and crime. However, as Elliott (1972) points out, one of the aims of case study research is to move from the particular to the general. In this chapter, I start by discussing the effect of being an ‘insider’ on my research and its impact on my findings. I then summarise my key findings before moving on to discuss three wider issues arising from my research: given the haphazard nature of television production is it possible, or even desirable, for representations of the police in these dramas to be authentic; is it the role of makers to provoke debate and inform; and, if so, does it necessarily follow that audiences will be receptive?