Abstract Commonly seen as ecclesiological enemies, the Scottish and congregational divines actually worked more closely together than any other group in the early part of the Puritan revolution. Led by George Gillespie, the Scots actually believed in a reformed polity that was more similar to congregational divines than it was to clerical (and influential) strains of English presbyterianism. By looking closely at documents written by George Gillespie, we see that there was a common ecclesiological basis for church reform that both the Scots and the congregational divines could subscribe to.