Social Sciences · Political Science and International Relations
The Victorian Crisis of Faith and the Faith That was Lost
See on the mapAbstract
In the past scholars have generally regarded Victorian faith in crisis as primarily an intellectual experience. They have tended to point to works of dissolvent literature associated with enlightenment rationalism, the higher criticism of the Bible, or new theories of physical science as the chief causes for particular persons modifying or rejecting the faith of their childhoods. The nineteenth-century documents recording the loss-of-faith experience in no small measure themselves led to that conclusion. In their autobiographies Victorian doubters or unbelievers often recalled the impact of advanced works of science, biblical criticism, or history upon their religious thought and then recounted the manner in which those new ideas had led them to renounce major Christian doctrines, to stop attending church, to change denominations, to leave the Christian ministry, or to embrace atheism, agnosticism, or some other substitute for traditional Christianity. Many of the loss-of-faith novels, such as Robert Elsmere (1888) and The Autobiography of Mark Rutherford (1881), embodied this same scenario. Furthermore, the earliest histories that examined the rise of religiously dissolvent literature, such as A Critical History of Free Thought (1862) by A.A. Farrar, History of Rationalism (1867) by J.F. Hurst, and The History of English Rationalism in the Nineteenth Century (1906) by A.W. Benn set forth this intellectualist analysis. Twentieth-century historians and literary scholars generally continued this mode of analysis. They rather uncritically assumed that intellectual factors or motivations alone must have moulded actions claimed by the Victorians to have been taken for intellectual reasons.