arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Social Sciences · Education

School-Based Drug Prevention: What Kind of Drug Use Does It Prevent?

Heather M. Helm

· The Journal of Law of Education

See on the map

Abstract

School-Based Drug Prevention: What Kind of Drug Use Does It Prevent? Few can argue against the importance of school-based prevention programs, or the need to evaluate their effectiveness. The increase in substance use across the life span, as well as a decrease in the age of initiation has amplified the imperativeness of prevention efforts. In our school systems a conflicting dynamic occurs as the availability of substances increases and the availability of prevention funding decreases. This dynamic highlights the need to not only evaluate the immediate effectiveness of prevention efforts, but also the pervasive, long-term effects of such efforts and whether the benefits of prevention outweigh the cost over the long-term. Through popular media such as television and the newspaper, we see reports of the physical, social, and familial effects of substance use and abuse forcing us to ask difficult questions about how to protect our youth from the potentially devastating effects. In their book School-Based Prevention: What Kind of Drug Use Does It Prevent Caulkins, Pacula, Paddock, and Cheisa (2002) ask several compelling and salient research questions. Specifically, Caulkins et. al., seek to quantify the long-term benefits of prevention beyond the school years and over the entire life span, as well as examine the distribution of prevention's benefits to society by the projecting the decrease in illicit substance use such as cocaine and marijuana and licit drugs such as alcohol and tobacco. The authors emphasize that such projections can provide insight into whether prevention primarily influences illicit drug use, with secondary influence on tobacco and alcohol use. Or, if prevention primarily prevents licit drug use, therefore proving to be more of a public health benefit as opposed to a law enforcement/drug treatment benefit. They go on to suggest the possible policy implications of such projections; specifically, who should finance prevention efforts and which exemplary programs should receive the limited resources available for these efforts. In general, the authors attempt to determine if the social benefits of school-based prevention outweigh the costs of implementing and maintaining the programs. Caulkins et. al. (2002) recognize and consistently account for the inexact nature of the extrapolation required to project the degree to which society is benefited by prevention efforts. Ways in which these extrapolations are accounted for are outlined early in the book. Specifically, the authors use a comprehensive ten-factor model for calculating both the social benefits of prevention efforts as well as the overall cost of substance use, specifically alcohol, tobacco, marijuana, and cocaine, on society. To fully examine the myriad of issues that influence the projection of the long-term benefits of prevention efforts, the authors consider the ten factors within four broader constructs, specifically; lifetime drug use per person in the absence of prevention, percentage reduction in lifetime use expected from prevention, adjustments to reduction in use, and social cost per unit of use. The empirical evidence used to develop this framework comes from evaluations of school-based prevention programs, surveys of drug use in the general population, and other published research. The authors emphasize that their results and projections are only as statistically sound as the empirical data used to draw their estimates of each of the ten factors. In reading the details and intricacies of this research it appears that the authors have thoroughly examined the challenges and limitations inherent in extrapolating and inferring quantitative data that is not available in any true scientific sense. …

More like this