Social Sciences · Education
Consequences of Different Styles of Textbook Use in Preparing Students for Standardized Tests.
See on the mapAbstract
Earlier content analyses conducted by the authors showed that the match between content covered by textbooks' and tests varied as a function of the particular textbook and test a teacher was asked to use. authors also tried to determine if the congruity in textbook-test content varied as a function of different styles of textbook use. Using yearlong case studies of seven teachers as a guide, the authors identified five distinct styles of textbook use. These ranged from a page-by-page progression through the book to the selection of only those lessons that conformed to a management-by-objectives system. authors then determined the match between content covered on each of five standardized tests and the lessons covered by each usage style of the Holt fourth-grade mathematics Despite clear limits to the generalizability of this study, the results support two important conclusions. 1. When a management-by-objectives system serves as the core of an indivdivalized approach to instructionlow achievement students may suffer serious handicaps in their opportunities to learn content covered on standardized tests. 2. Overall levels of student performance on standardized tests of achievement may be relatively insensitive to variation in the content of classroom instruction resulting from differences in how teachers use textbooks. CONSEQUENCES OF DIFFERENT STYLES OF TEXTBOOK USE IN PREPARING STUDENTS FOR STANDARDIZED TESTS1 Donald J. Freeman, Gabriella M. Belli, Andrew C. Porter, Robert E. Floden, William H. Schmidt, and John R. Schwille2 Educators and researchers agree that textbooks greatly influence what is taught. Therefore, it is not surprising that our year-long case studies of seven elementary-sehool teachers3 support the results of national surveys: that, for'most teachers, textbooks are an important determinant of what is taught (National Committee on Mathematics Education, Note 1). In a series of interview questions focusing on teiabook use in fourth-grade mathematics instruction, one case-study teacher remarked, Most people will teach whaj is in the book, so what is being taught depends on what is in the math book. In a comparable interview, a principal stated, The math book is a curriculum, you might say, for the district....The curriculum itself is pretty much oriented to the textbook. Many believe that in elementary-school mathematics a national curriculum guides the development of textbooks and tests and that when teachers rely on textbooks in deciding what to teach, they provide an opportunity for students to learn what is tested in standardized tests. Similarly, they expect that the commonly used standardized tests of elementary-school mathematics are so similar in content that they may be used interchangeably. 1. This paper has been submitted to the Journal of Educational Measurement. 2. Donald Freeman is a professor in the Department of Teacher Education. Gabriella Belli was a research assistant on the Content Determinants Project in the IRT. Andrew Porter is the project's director. Robert Floden is an associate professor in the Department of Teacher Education. William Schmidt is the chairperson of the Department of Counseling, Educational Psychology and Special Education. John Schwille is a professor in the Department oi Teacher Education. 3. results of the case study investigations will be summarized in a forthcoming monograph.