Social Sciences · Political Science and International Relations
Once a Foreigner, Always a Foreigner. Who Does Not Belong Here Anymore? Expulsion Measures
See on the mapAbstract
This paper analyses some of the case law on Union citizens’ residency rights and expulsion measures on grounds of public policy and security. This case law favours a narrow interpretation of Union citizenship to the effect that it is the state of nationality that bears primary responsibility for its citizens. As a result, only acquisition of the nationality of the host State (a matter entirely regulated by national law) will transform the migrant Union citizen in a full member of the host society. The paper argues that such a narrow interpretation seems to betray the transnational roots of Union citizenship: after all, the very idea behind Union citizenship should be to allow Union citizens, at least to a certain extent, to decide where they want to belong, so as to replace the belonging-by-birth typical of the national state rhetoric, with a new belonging-by-choice, more in line with the ambitions of a ‘special space’, the European Union, which is neither national nor international. It is possible that something of this ideal might be saved, especially by restating a role for Article 21 TFEU in relation to the rights to reside of Union citizens. Yet, the Court’s interpretation of when the Member States are entitled to severe a Union citizen from her polity of choice is a stark reminder that, at least in the eyes of the Court, Union citizenship impacts very little on imbedded notions of self and otherness. Once a foreigner always a foreigner.