Social Sciences · Law
A Legislative Response to Tiffany V. Ebay: In Search of an Online Commerce Certification Act (OCCA)
See on the mapAbstract
Our economy is badly weakened, a consequence of greed and irresponsibility on the part of some, but also our collective failure to make hard choices and prepare the Nation for a new age. (1) I. INTRODUCTION Counterfeit products are a cancer on the global economy, whether in the form of cheap replicas of high-end Gucci[R] handbags or knock-offs of household Duracell[R] batteries. (2) However, because the sale of counterfeit goods is perceived as a victimless offense (3) too burdensome for law enforcement to combat aggressively, (4) counterfeit goods have proliferated in the global marketplace at an alarming rate. (5) The online commercial marketplace is certainly no exception. (6) Enforcement of intellectual property rights (7) against the numerous agents in the counterfeiting food chain is often described as a 'whack-a-mole.' (8) The online marketplace is no different, but it is beset by additional complications. (9) Intellectual property rights owners (IPROs) have attempted to stay apace with the counterfeiters, relying on numerous strategies to combat the trafficking of counterfeit goods both on and offline. As can be expected, the widespread and global nature of counterfeit trafficking makes coordinating an effective anti-counterfeiting effort a herculean task, even for IPROs with a well-funded legal budget. (10) As such, the chief litigation strategy for IPROs in combating online trafficking of counterfeits has been to take action against parties that enable and facilitate the counterfeit trade. (11) According to IPROs, counterfeiters found fertile ground for purveying their knock-offs on the online auction site provided by eBay, Inc. (eBay). (12) & Co. (13) (Tiffany) filed suit against eBay, alleging that, from 2003 to 2006 alone, hundreds of thousands of counterfeit TIFFANY (14) silver jewelry pieces were offered for sale on eBay's website. (15) While sued eBay on multiple theories, (16) the district court focused primarily on Tiffany's legal theory that eBay was liable for contributory trademark infringement, as eBay was the online host facilitating and benefitting from the third-party sale of counterfeit TIFFANY products. (17) The district court required eBay to have sufficient Knowledge that particular users were purveying counterfeit products on its platform, and did nothing to impede such sales, in order to impute contributory trademark infringement to eBay. (18) Although the Second Circuit Court of Appeals had not yet determined how much of infringing activity is necessary to impute liability to an online host, the district court ruled, and the Second Circuit recently affirmed, that knowledge was necessary. (19) As a result of its factual findings, the district court concluded that eBay was not contributorily liable for trademark infringement even though IPROs suspected that individual sellers were selling counterfeit goods on the eBay site; (20) eBay must have had specific that certain offerings on its site were counterfeit yet did nothing to impede those transactions. (21) Furthermore, the district court found that whenever eBay received specific of a user's counterfeit activities, eBay took the necessary action to suspend service and remove the appropriate listings. (22) In brief, the litigation can best be characterized as an attempt by a major IPRO to obstruct a major conduit for the trafficking of counterfeit goods. (23) Instead of pursuing the individual eBay sellers purveying suspect Tiffany products, Tiffany's strategy was to pursue the hornet's nest itself. (24) To Tiffany's chagrin, the district court found that eBay had been implementing a legal compliance strategy that was consonant with the interests of IPROs, in addition to being well within the bounds of their legal duties. (25) The major issue between online hosts and IPROs, the contours of which litigation seems unlikely to change in the near future (in the U. …