arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Social Sciences · Political Science and International Relations

Political Theory and Criminal Punishment: Introduction

Mary Sigler

· The Knowledge Bank (The Ohio State University)

See on the map

Abstract

The scholarly literature on punishment—its general justification and allocation, its forms and processes—is vast indeed. The discourse ranges from the seemingly intractable philosophical debate between retributive and utilitarian accounts of punishment’s legitimate purpose to more practical considerations involving trials, sentencing, and implementation. We are, in short, preoccupied with punishment. This is as it should be, for criminal punishment involves what is perhaps the most profound and awesome exercise of the state’s formidable power. Absent a compelling justification, the sort of hard treatment that constitutes punishment—the deprivation of life, liberty, or property—would itself represent a grave injustice, especially in a liberal democratic polity. But for all of the thoughtful discussion of punishment’s many facets, the relationship between punishment and political theory has received relatively little sustained attention, especially in legal scholarship. 1 In some cases this omission reflects an affirmative rejection of the relevance of political theory to questions of criminal punishment; 2

More like this