arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Social Sciences · Political Science and International Relations

The Law of Appropriateness: An Approach to a General Theory of Intergovernmental Relations

David J. Kennedy

· Public Administration Review

See on the map

Abstract

D uring a number of years of studying and lecturing about the American federal system, I have been dismayed by the virtually total absence of any formalized statement of the principles underlying its inner workings. True, there has been no lack of published work on the subject of American intergovernmental relations on the contrary one feels overwhelmed by its bulk yet, most of the writing has been essentially normative, describing the structure without developing any basic rules about its controlling dynamics. Noting that my concern was shared by a number of public administrators at the local, state, and federal levels of government, and encouraged by a number of successful investigations of related questions,1 I set about the task of formulating some rather easily observable axioms about intergovernmental relations with the hope that a general theory, or at least an approach to such a theory, would emerge. In doing so, I was fully aware of the appalling lack of statistical and other empirical evidence in the field and was quite prepared to treat the results of my investigation as preliminary to more extended research. As is so often the case in scientific inquiry, the outlines of the basic law governing intergovernmental relations evolved more from insight rather than investigation. The development of its corollaries and related principles required the testing of innumerable applications of the law on case histories and hypothetical models. The ultimate truth of the body of doctrine must, of course, await more complete demonstration, but it should be stated that in the work I have concluded thus far, the law has proved immutable, or nearly so. * The system of American intergovernmental relations is traditionally approached by observing how it operates rather than analyzing why it works as it does. Presented here is the first and probably the last attempt to develop some general principles about the federal system cast in terms that the practitioner of public administration can understand, or at least pretend to understand. The concept of appropriateness in intergovernmental relations, though simple, is not simple-minded, and perhaps is closer to true principles than more complex analyses of the subject.

More like this