arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Social Sciences · Political Science and International Relations

Democracy’s Muse: How Thomas Jefferson Became an FDR Liberal, a Reagan Republican, and a Tea Party Fanatic, All While Being Dead

Jeffrey J. Malanson

· Political Science Quarterly

See on the map

Abstract

For more than 200 years, Americans have tried to make sense of the present by looking to the past. In Democracy’s Muse, historian Andrew Burstein examines the many versions of Thomas Jefferson that politicians from the Great Depression to the present have used to explain modern American politics and culture. Jefferson is a fitting focus of this study, as, in Burstein’s estimation, “he is the one ‘founding father’ whose political sentiments reverberate loudest” throughout American history (p. ix). Burstein opens with several chapters exploring the myriad ways that Franklin D. Roosevelt, John F. Kennedy, Ronald Reagan, Bill Clinton, and others used Jefferson to support their political agendas. Burstein is less interested in making any particular argument about how Jefferson was used than he is in revealing the “several noticeable facelifts” that Jefferson “passively endured” (p. ix). Some readers may wish for a stronger analytical framework, but this approach serves two important purposes. By eschewing a specific argument in favor of a more open-ended exploration, readers can better understand both the lens through which presidents asked Americans to view Jefferson and the historical context in which those presidents used Jefferson. The exploratory nature of the first half of Democracy’s Muse also makes Burstein’s analysis of the culture wars surrounding Jefferson in the second half of the book much more impactful. Chapters on race and religion are highly effective at demonstrating why it is important to interrogate modern-day uses of the past and of Jefferson in particular. Many Americans, including many of Jefferson’s heirs, have rejected the possibility that the author of the Declaration of Independence could have fathered children with one of his slaves, Sally Hemings, even in face of DNA evidence and overwhelming logic. Burstein persuasively asserts that such rejections, and the discourse surrounding them, raise difficult questions about the way we understand the historical Jefferson and about race and racism today.

More like this