Social Sciences · Political Science and International Relations
Institutional Approach between ihl and ihrl
See on the mapAbstract
Recently, the interaction between international human rights law ( ihrl ) and international humanitarian law ( ihl ) has been significantly developed by the jurisprudence of the Inter-American Court of Human Rights ( iac t hr ). This article analyzes this recent trend from the cases of the Santo Domingo Massacre and Afro communities displaced from the Cacarica River Basin ( Operation Genesis ) of this tribunal to assert its competence not only to use ihl to interpret the Inter-American human rights instruments but, at the same time, to approach a direct use of humanitarian standards, which creates a gray area between the interpretation and application of such area of law. In doing so, the Court resorts to the lex specialis , if the ihl norm is the most specialized for the case, and uses ihl to a limited extent, only to expand the content of human rights, but not to judge on possible violations of ihl , which results in a methodology of pick and choose of ihl provisions.