Social Sciences · Political Science and International Relations
Alexander Hamilton and Julius Caesar: A Note on the Use of Historical Evidence
See on the mapAbstract
D UMAS Malone, in second volume of his biography of Thomas Jefferson, observes that it oversimplifies the bitter political conflict which developed during Presidency of George view it a duel, or succession of duels, between Thomas Jefferson and Alexander Hamilton. The conflict was more fundamental, involving ideas that run through whole of American national history, and Malone concludes with statement that other American statesman has personified national power and rule of favored few so well as Hamilton, and no other has glorified self-government and freedom of individual such a degree as Jefferson.' The difference between them, according Malone, was demonstrated at a dinner meeting at Jefferson's house during early years of Washington administration, when Hamilton, noticing unidentified portraits of Francis Bacon, Isaac Newton, and John Locke, asked who they were: They were his 'trinity of three greatest men world had ever produced,' Jefferson said, but they meant little or nothing in Hamilton's philosophy. 'The greatest man that ever lived,' said Colonel, 'was Julius Caesar.' 2 Julian Boyd, editor of Jefferson's papers, also states that Hamilton considered Caesar be one of greatest figures of history, and attributes Hamilton's influence and information assertion by LouisGuillaume Otto, French charge d'affaires, that Washington, in all things, seemed to wish resemble Caesar.3 The late Douglass Adair similarly asserts that Hamilton admired Caesar above all men who had ever lived, and charges that in his ambition be seated on highest summit of his country's honors, Hamilton was the one major leader among our Founding Fathers who had