arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Social Sciences · Law

Two Unhappy Dilemmas for Natural Law Jurisprudence

Mark C. Murphy

· The American Journal of Jurisprudence

See on the map

Abstract

Recent engagement with natural law accounts of law’s nature have been at a high level of abstraction, arguing either that the whole jurisprudential enterprise is wrongheaded or that there is no plausible thesis concerning law’s nature that is distinctively a natural law thesis. This paper addresses versions of both of these attacks. Against recent claims that law’s status as an artifact entails that it has no nature to be discovered, it is argued that on any sense of ‘artifact’ in which law is an artifact, there are necessary truths about artifactual kinds that at least partially constitute what it is to be an artifact of that kind. Against the claim that legal positivists can affirm every plausible thesis about law that natural lawyers want to assert, it is argued that there are plausible natural law theses that entail the falsity of the canonical formulations of basic positivist theses. The only viable line of attack against natural law jurisprudence is to engage with specific natural law arguments about law’s nature, not to reject out of hand that law has a nature or that natural law theory says something distinctive about that nature.

More like this