arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Social Sciences · Law

Law Clerking at the Supreme Court of Canada

Michael J. Herman

· Osgoode Hall law journal

See on the map

Abstract

There are ordinarily nine legal secretaries (law clerks 1 ) at the Supreme Court of Canada, allotted one per Justice, 2 serving either one or two year terms.The relationship between Judge and clerk is usually informal; the dialogue is candid.Naturally, they discuss the merits of the cases coming up for hearing; but, additionally, the conversation can be about more general jurisprudential themes, such as the appropriate role for the Supreme Court of Canada, or the quality of the judgments emanating from the Court.Accordingly, all communications are confidential.The clerk is administered an oath of office and acts on the implicit understanding that the Judge's words are meant for the clerk's ears alone.Let me impose one qualification.The Judges promote the clerks' practice of discussing cases amongst themselves.Indeed, the working quarters encourage this flow of ideas: all the desks are situated in a single, large, highceilinged room, separated only by book shelves acting as partiti6ns.These collaborations inevitably cause the clerks to reveal approaches suggested by or concerns voiced by the Judges.But the employers' thoughts are disclosed only to aid the fuller discussion of the case and the better formulation of a legal solution.This limited sharing of the judicial confidence is ordinarily permissible.

More like this