Abstract
SEVERAL Research columns have reported on studies of the educational impact of changing schools (January 1989, May 1989, May 1991, and September 1994). These studies have been uniformly negative. However, they have been conducted on elementary and middle school students only. Moreover, the research has not differentiated between those who change schools because of a move and those who simply change schools. Christopher Swanson and Barbara Schneider of the University of Chicago make such a distinction. These researchers come up with four categories of students: movers those who change residence but not school; changers those who change school but not residence; leavers those who change school and residence at the same time; and stayers those who do neither. Using the NELS:88-94 database, Swanson and Schneider determined that 29% of students in grades 8-10 are mobile in some form and that 24% of students in grades 10-12 change school, residence, or both. (Grade 10 appears as part of both the early high school years and the late high school years. This is because the data are organized so that each category occupies 21U2 years. The first category runs from grade 8 through the first half of grade 10, and the second category from the second half of grade 10 to the end of grade 12.) In grades 8-10, some 13% of students were movers, while 11.5% were changers. In grades 10-12, though, movers out-numbered changers 3 to 1. Leavers were a small percentage at both levels: 4.7% in grades 8-10 and 3.5% in grades 10-12. Some 71% of students in grades 8-10 and 76% of students in grades 10-12 stayed put. The different kinds of mobility have different outcomes. So does the matter of the timing of the changes. The researchers looked at three outcomes: behavioral problems, dropping out, and mathematics achievement. The last was chosen because its cumulative nature was presumed to make it most sensitive to mobility. The results reported below are those that remain significant after ethnicity, marital status, and other socioeconomic variables have been removed from the analyses. That is, these are independent effects of some type of move. Changing homes or changing schools had no immediate impact on math achievement for those in grades 8-10. However, students who changed schools or who changed homes but not schools during this period had significantly greater gains in mathematics in the later high school years than those in the other groups. Students who were movers or changers early in their high school careers did not show any noticeable increase in behavioral problems, but those who moved or changed later on did. Students who were changers or leavers before 10th grade were more likely to be early dropouts than students who remained at one school (stayers and movers of residence only). If the changers or leavers weathered the transition, however, they were less likely to drop out than those who had stayed in one school. The researchers conclude: The higher rate of early dropout found among all types of mobile students cautions us that even educational mobility, which can improve a student's prospects in the long run, can place a student in jeopardy in the short run. Students who change schools between 8th and 10th grades are significantly more likely to remain in high school through their senior year, but only if they can weather the difficult period of adjustment immediately following the transition. However, changing schools after the 10th grade, regardless of a students' family background or academic history, rarely results in beneficial educational outcomes and is likely to have a substantial negative impact on a student's cognitive growth. The Rising Tide IN AN ODD turn of events, the Index of Social Health started a precipitous decline around 1976, just about the time that achievement test scores bottomed out and started back up. The climb of test scores in light of problems in our nation's social institutions still seems remarkable. …