Social Sciences · Sociology and Political Science
Tasting Freedom: Octavius Catto and the Battle for Equality in Civil War America
See on the mapAbstract
This is a densely contextualized life history of one of Philadelphia's most prominent mid-nineteenth-century free black activists, Octavius Valentine Catto (1839–1871). Daniel R. Biddle and Murray Dubin skillfully situate their subject at the center of multiple concentric circles. At the farthest distance from the core is the Atlantic world—Liberia, England, Ireland, Canada, Haiti, Panama—places of expatriation and repatriation for African Americans and places from which they drew symbolic support in their struggle for full citizenship and slavery's abolition. There are more tightly drawn regional circles for analyzing race relations as well—the North, the South, the Midwest, the West. The tightest geographical circle in which the authors examine Catto is Pennsylvania and Philadelphia. There, Catto and his peers navigate a triangulated course for citizenship among Quakers and abolitionists, anti-black Irish and Democrats, and nativist or business-minded Whig or Republican allies. The narrative is an exposé of the antebellum North and of Philadelphia as “the northernmost Southern city” (p. 246). William Catto, an ordained Protestant minister with flexible denominational loyalties, moved his family in 1848 from South Carolina to Pennsylvania for a better life. Yet free blacks in Philadelphia could not vote, ride streetcars with whites, easily attend school, or expect equal employment opportunities. Above the Mason-Dixon line, African Americans might encounter laws limiting their in-migration. The fear of race amalgamation was ubiquitous. Mercenary slave catchers operated illegally or with dubious legal authority, snatching African Americans off streets and selling them into bondage. And everywhere, the prospect of racial equality caused whites to riot and instigate violent mobs against African Americans at the slightest provocation.