arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Social Sciences · Political Science and International Relations

The Quiet Referendum: Why Electoral Reform Failed in Ontario

Lawrence LeDuc, Heather Bastedo, Catherine Baquero

See on the map

Abstract

1Ontario's 2007 referendum on electoral reform, which resulted in the retention of the present first-past-the-post electoral system, was the culmination of a multi-layered exercise in deliberative and participatory democracy. Although the proposed electoral system reform was rejected in the October 10th referendum, the process that led to that outcome was nevertheless an important experiment in involving citizens directly in a major political decision making process, both in providing for deliberation of the issue by a body of ordinary citizens and in reserving the final decision on the issue to the voters. In this paper, we examine the sequence of events from the beginning in the commissioning of a Citizens ' Assembly by the Ontario government, the process of deliberation that took place over the eight months that the Assembly met, its recommendation for a change in the electoral system used in provincial elections in Ontario, the structure of the referendum campaign that followed, and the voting outcome.1 A detailed comparative analysis of this important experiment in both deliberative and direct democracy can teach us much about the strengths and limitations of citizen engagement in institutional reform, but also about the challenges in communication that such a process involves. This analysis will begin with a review of a successful case of reform in New Zealand,

More like this