Social Sciences · Political Science and International Relations
Spreading the Gospel in Colonial Virginia: Sermons and Devotional Writings
See on the mapAbstract
Spreading the Gospel in Colonial Virginia: Sermons and Devotional Writings. Introduction and notes by Edward L. Bond. Lanham, Maryland: Lexington Books, in association with Colonial Williamsburg Foundation, 2004. Pp. xvii + 569. $199.00. At its simplest level, this is a book of documents on life in colonial Virginia. The collection seeks to capture the variety of expression, and to have some balance between laity and clergy. The book does not include sermons by some well-known people, often because such documents are widely available, mainly political, too derivative (read plagiarized), or too long. The documents appear as they might have been in the eighteenth century, although he corrects obvious printing and spelling errors. The book has the great advantage of giving scholars ready access to pamphlets otherwise available only in major research libraries. The volume is a bit large for people to capture all its nuances in a single read, and the absence of an index is a disadvantage. Still the book is really excellent and recommended to anyone interested in religion in colonial America. The book begins with an introductory essay that neatly summarizes the state of the literature. The introduction, while an exceptionally fine read, does not explicitly set the stage for the documents that follow. The chapter begins with an arresting vignette pitting a Quaker missionary disputing with an Anglican minister in 1705 on fourteen points, but most tellingly on baptism and the nature of sin. He observes that people were more engaged in debate, well-informed, and open to ideas than historians usually credit. Anglicans were not in control and people were interested in religion and tolerant of divergent views. While not dominant, Bond argues that the Anglicans provided good and sufficient clergy on an improving basis from, say, 1725 to 1775. The Church of England held no hegemony, but did have some privileges, was an agent of government, and provided religious guidance and solace to nearly all Virginians (45). Rather than stress the struggle of dissenters to gain rights, Bond stresses a peaceful coexistence that was longstanding. Bond is persuasive. The documents are arranged in eight chapters. Robert Paxton, James Blair, James Maury, Samuel Davies, and John Leland each get a chapter. Paxton, as a preacher bringing English approaches to the James River of the 1710s, was educating the congregation by making the otherwise inaccessible accessible; what were current ideas on angels, Christ's crucifixion, and the holy communion? Blair was more eloquent, and more original; he expected his work to be published (and 117 sermons were published in five volumes in 1722). Bond comments that Blair's sermons seem practical, but that he believes in faith as essential to work. Bond also comments that Blair's sermons are typical of his Church; what evidence do we need before we can say that? …