arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Social Sciences · Education

Certify, Blink, Hire: An Examination of the Process and Tools of Teacher Screening and Selection

Stacey A. Rutledge, Douglas N. Harris, Cynthia T. Thompson, W. Kyle Ingle

· Leadership and Policy in Schools

See on the map

Abstract

Abstract While much has been written about the process of employee selection in other occupations, there has been little discussion on the process and tools of teacher selection and why it occurs as it does. To understand this question, we conduct an extensive literature review in which we compare teacher hiring with hiring in other occupations. We also present findings from a study of school principals and district administrators in a midsized Florida school district. Our results suggest that the screening and selection process in teaching is not much different from occupations that have similar levels of job complexity. A theory emerges from the review and analysis that explains the process and reliance on certain tools in teacher hiring. The theory focuses especially on the costs of various tools and processes, the types and quality of information that come from them, and the distinctive features of teaching as an occupation and schools as organizations. View correction statement:Erratum The authors gratefully acknowledge the financial support of the United States Department of Education, Institute for Education Sciences. We would also like to thank Robert Floden, David Monk, and Andrew Shouse for their comments on an earlier version of this article. The statements made and views expressed are solely the responsibility of the authors. Notes 1. We choose to focus on screening and selection because they are the two steps of the process that are primarily under the control of school and district administrators. Recruitment of teachers involves district, state, and federal actors. The job offer is usually a formality overseen by the district. 2. See CitationLiu & Johnson (2006) for a discussion of the importance of the P-O fit in the context of the retention of new teachers. 3. See CitationDarling-Hammond, Wise, & Pease (1983) for models of the organization of teaching. 4. We identified eight studies in our review of research that provided data that was relevant to our study. Seven of the studies obtained data from surveys of principals and school administrators who had responsibility for teacher hiring in their districts. One study compared the responses of undergraduate students, teacher educators, and principals. The surveys sought respondents' views about the relative importance of certain characteristics and other attributes desired in an applicant. None of the studies focused on screening or selection tools. Instead, the researchers included a mix of characteristics and tools in the surveys. For this paper, we draw only on the information related to our discussion of selection tools. 5. Studies have considered candidate age and maturity, which are arguably related to experience. CitationYoung and Voss (1986) find that in simulated settings there is a preference for younger candidates, while CitationYoung and Pounder (1985) find that age is not a major influence for decisions made on the basis of interviews. As a result, CitationPounder (1987) indicates that the results are mixed regarding the role of candidate age. 6. Some principals who were interviewed in the first year retired or left in the second year. The principals who replaced them were included in the second interview. 7. Principals in our study did not technically “hire” the teachers; however in practice, principals' recommendations to the district were rarely overridden. 8. The national data on principals comes from the 1999–2000 Schools and Staffing Survey (SASS) as reported in the Digest of Education Statistics (National Center for Education Statistics, 2004). 9. In order to test whether the interviewed principals were representative of the district, we compared some of the measured characteristics of the schools (percent of students who are minority, percent FRL, Title I status) and principals (race and gender) with those of the interviewed principals. No statistically significant differences were found with one exception: the percentage of principals in the

More like this