Abstract
The History of Panama by Robert C. Harding is plagued by so many mistakes of fact and is so biased in its interpretations that it fails to accomplish the main goal of the Greenwood Histories of Modern Nations series, to provide “students and interested laypeople with up-to-date, concise, and analytical histories of many of the nations of the contemporary world.”In part, these faults originate from the author’s apparent lack of knowledge regarding the most recent historiography on Panama by both national and foreign historians. Harding mentions only three Panamanian historians (Bonifacio Pereira, Ricaurte Soler, and Alfredo Castillero Calvo), and the books he refers to are general overviews instead of existing research monographs. Therefore, the wide, complex, and well-researched articles and books produced in the last ten years have not been considered.Regarding U.S. historians, Harding does not consider the contributions produced after 1992 by academics like Michael L. Conniff, Thomas L. Pearcy, Aims C. McGuinness, and Peter A. Szok. Though Harding mentions Michael LaRosa and German Mejía’s The United States Discovers Panama: The Writing of Soldiers, Scholars, Scientists and Scoundrels, 1850 – 1905 (2004), he does not use these travelers’ descriptions of Panama during the nineteenth century to provide a more balanced, accurate image of Panama, its peoples, and its cultures.This disregard of readily available literature perhaps explains why “Galván” appears in the name of Rodrigo de Bastidas (not “de Las Bastidas”), the first entry included in the “Timeline of Historical Events.” Among other grievous errors in this timeline are the author’s suggestions that the National Police supported Acción Comunal’s 1931 coup d’état, or that 120 students died in “Operation Sovereignty” in 1958.In the first chapter, “Panama is a Canal and More,” Harding maintains that “Panama’s modern political system is the direct result of its long relationship with the United States” (p. 9). In fact, Panama’s first constitution drew largely from Colombia’s 1886 constitution. Moreover, Spanish and French judiciary traditions inspired Panama’s legal system, differing markedly from the British and U.S. models. Also, the executive branch of the Panamanian government does not resemble the U.S model.The first paragraph of chapter 3, “Completing the Canal to World War II,” ends with an inaccurate statement that reflects the author’s uninformed biases: “However, the construction of the canal would build more than just a waterway; it would eventually forge a nation” (p. 27). Harding badly oversimplifies the complex process on nation building, which in the Panamanian case began early in the colonial period and developed during Panama’s union to Colombia in the nineteenth century. The intervention of the United States was key to Panama’s separation from Colombia and the subsequent establishment of an independent Panamanian state, but not to the development of the Panamanian nation. This chapter contains many other fundamental mistakes: Panama was recognized by the United States Department of State on November 6, 1903, not November 13; Manuel Amador Guerrero, Pablo Arosemena, and José Domingo de Obaldía did not form part of the revolutionary “Junta de Gobierno”; the labor force that built the Panama Canal was not integrated “mostly” by Panamanians (the truth is that very few local workers participated in the canal’s construction); before Colonel George W. Goethals assumed the leadership of the Panama Canal Commission, John Frank Stevens was its chief engineer, and under his civilian administration not only did Doctor William Gorgas launch his historic sanitation campaign, but also detailed plans for a locks canal were approved; and finally, the first ship to use the canal was the Alexandre La Valley (January 7, 1914), not the Cristobal.Chapter 4, “Panama during the Cold War,” correctly deals with the emergence of nationalistic forces and movements demanding Panamani