Social Sciences · Political Science and International Relations
The 'Overload Thesis' and Canadian Government
See on the mapAbstract
Can governments govern any more? Can they make and implement policies to deal with the complex demands and the multiple social conflicts of advanced industrial society? Increasingly commentators and government leaders themselves answer no. Samuel Huntingdon sees a sharp decline in the 'governability' of modern societies. Even more important than the question 'who governs?', he suggests, is the question 'does anybody govern?' (Huntingdon, I975:23). 'It was once thought that Britain was an unusually easy country to govern, its politicians wise, its parties responsible, its administration efficient, its people docile,' writes Anthony King. 'Now we wonder whether Britain is not perhaps an unusually difficult country to govern, its problems peculiarly intractable, its people increasingly bloody-minded.' What has happened, he asks, what has gone wrong? (King, I975:284). Richard Rose observes that 'Something has happened to government and to our belief in government in the last decade' (Rose, I975:I4). It results in a political malaise which is in some respects more severe than that of the Great Depression, and which may constitute a threat to the continued existence of representative government itself. Where once there was optimism that governments could confidently act as agents of collective decision, managing, directing and steering the economy and society along chosen paths, the image today is more, as King points out, that of government as the sorcerer's apprentice: 'The waters rise. The apprentice rushes around with his bucket. The waters rise even faster. And none of us knows when, or whether, the magician will come home' (King, I975:286). This pervasive sometimes apocalyptic pessimism represents a remarkable shift of opinion from that prevailing only a few years ago. The optimism of the early sixties suggested that everything was possible. Through government, men could be masters of their fate. Governments, many felt, now possessed the tools Keynesian economics, new techniques of policy analysis, ever-growing material and intellectual resources which, coupled with political will, meant that poverty could be beaten, depressed industries revived, economic growth perpetuated. Similarly, 'the politics of consensus