arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Social Sciences · Political Science and International Relations

Toleration in Conflict: Past and Present, by Rainer Forst

Cary J. Nederman

· The English Historical Review

See on the map

Abstract

Generally speaking, the scholarly literature concerning toleration (or tolerance—terms which will be employed here interchangeably) has been sharply divided between two approaches. The first may be termed philosophical: effort is directed toward parsing and analysing the conceptual elements of toleration in order to identify the salient feature(s) that comprise tolerant practices, as well as the conditions and limits thereof. This philosophical perspective is usually tied to a broader account of liberal–democratic society and institutions. A second mode in which tolerance has been understood is historical in character: it posits that toleration in both theory and practice depends upon the emergence of specific circumstances that render it possible. Thus, tolerance rests primarily upon context, rather than on philosophical principles. The distinction between these divergent models has been quite overt and pronounced. (Indeed, I know of one philosopher of toleration who proudly proclaims that she has read no historical texts on the topic other than Locke and Mill, and only then for the intellectual substance of their [liberal] defences of tolerance.) Although some philosophers, such as John Rawls in the introduction to his Political Liberalism, allude briefly to historical conditions (in particular, the Reformation and its aftermath) and some historians attempt to draw conceptual lessons from their studies, the logical relationship between philosophy and history is purely contingent as matters now stand.

More like this

The Church

Lee Ward

Sociology and Political Science · Cambridge University Press eBooks · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ ·