Social Sciences · Sociology and Political Science
Forty years on: French writing on 1968 in 2008
See on the mapAbstract
Every ten years after the events of 1968 in France, there has been a spate of publications about this pivotal moment in the twentieth century. In 1978, the Maoist leader Robert Linhart published his experience of ‘going to the people’ as a car worker in L’Etabli. 1988 saw the publication of Laurent Joffrin's Mai 68. Histoire des événements and Génération by Hervé Hamon and Patrick Rotman, a collective biography of the Paris-centred intellectual leadership of 1968, especially the Maoists. In 1998, Jean-Pierre Le Goff attacked what he saw as the hedonistic, amoral project of 1968 in Mai 68, l'héritage impossible, an attack that was resumed by Nicolas Sarkozy during the presidential election campaign of 2007, when he vowed to ‘liquidate 1968’. In 2008, the challenge has been not only to rescue 1968 from political condescension but to widen the historical lens to situate it in a larger chronological and geographical context. Fifteen books are reviewed here, written both by historians and by former militants. They are analysed first in terms of their chronological scope, with les années 68 now becoming the standard time frame, and their geographical scope—how far the provinces are included alongside Paris, and international and transnational perspectives as well as purely French ones. Second, we explore whether they consider 1968 as predominantly a political revolt or alternatively a cultural revolt, a view that has become popular since the publication of Arthur Marwick's The Sixties in 1998. The issue of whether there was any connection between faith, a crisis of faith and revolt is also discussed. The nature of 1968 as a generational revolt continues to be widely discussed, but the question of whether the French 1968 and post-1968, compared to the Italian and German models, involved any violence, still demands serious reflection. The claim of the former head of the military wing of the Maoist Gauche Prolétarienne, that they did not indulge in violence because they were graduates of the Ecole Normale Supérieure imbued with Kantian altruism, can no longer be taken at face value.1 Lastly, we ask what sources are now being used to write the history of 1968 and, in particular, what is the status of oral testimony. The orthodox view among French academics, from Halbwachs to Nora and Rousso, is that memory is partial and partisan, while history is universal and objective, so that the first is of no use to the second. Simply to ignore the contribution of oral testimony, which since Portelli is not about reliability but about making sense of the past, is however to forfeit access to a rich and largely untapped resource.