Mathematics · Statistics and Probability
What Should We Call People? Race, Class, and the Census for 2000.
See on the mapAbstract
THE IMPENDING debate over the definition of race to be used in the U.S. Census for the year 2000 could be the most divisive debate over racial issues since the I Mos. Moreover, the subject is of great importance to education at all lev@ els. In this article I will attempt to explain the problem, review its history, and ex@ amine the options for the future. Who Defines Race? In the U.S. the answer to this question is crystal clear@ the Office of Management and Budget TOMB J, reporting to the House Committee on Post Office and Civil Service, Subcommittee on Census, Statistics, and Postal Personnel. While this subcommittee does not represent the most desirable political plum in the Congress, it has been at the center of a swirling debate on the nature of racial designations, as seen in hearings that began in 1993 and continued into 1994, though they were virtually ignored by the news media. Since 1977 the racial/ethnic categories that can be used on all federal forms have come from OMB Statistical Directive 15, which allows only four racial groups, designated by the following headings American Indian/Alaskan Native, Asian/pacific Islander, Black, and White. Ethnicity is broken down into Hispanic and non-hispanic. These are the categories that are used on application forms for jobs, on school enrollment forms, on mortgage applications, and on college scholarship and loan applications. They are also the boxes we must check (choosing only one) on the U.S. Census form. The govenment does not gather information of this kind just out of idle curiosity, these categories are used by federal agencies to search for job discrimination and segregated schools and to give out large chunks of federal aid. There could be other ramifications as well. For exam@ ple, it was clear that the suggestion in late IN@ that Hawaiians be classified not as Asian/pacific Islanders but as Native Americans was made at least in part to al@ low Hawaiians to operate gambling casi@ nos, a right currently reserved only for Na@ tive Americans. A Short History of Racial Classification in the U.S. The Constitution requires that a census be conducted every 10 years in order to revise the structure of the House of Representatives so that it reflects the real population of the more radical political ideas ever implemented. Since the original U. S. Census of 1790, which was supervised by Thomas Jefferson, virtually every Census has defined race differently. The first allowed for free white males, free white females, other persons (including free blacks and taxable Indians) and slaves.[2] Even in 1790 it was clear that many slaves bad lighter skins than their masters, making a division between and mulatto seem logical. But mulattos were needed in the slave pool. In order to increase the size of the slave population, theone of blood,, rule appeared. That is, even of blood,,defined a person as and meant thai any child of a slave and a slave owner would be considered eligible for slavery. Over time, this rule enlarged the slave pool considerably. (The issue of whether of white defined you as white apparently never came up. The one drop rule has never been applied to Asians or Hispanics, but it was affirmed as the law of the land by the U.S. Supreme Court as late as 1986.[3] In our time, the 1960 Census allowed only two categories: white or nonwhite. In 1970 we could be white, black, or other, but by 1990 we had the four racial/ethnic categories established by OMB Statistical Directive 15, with 13 choices within the Asian group, ranging from Chinese to Thai, and with ethnicity broken into Hispanic subcategories for Mexican, Puerto Rican, Cuban, and other. Through most of our history, we believed that black blood was a reality, although today we know that there are four major human types - A, B, O, and AB - that are distributed across all racial categories. …